23 October 2017

Just joking


I saw a coyote out on the farm in a field where rice had recently been cut, in the late afternoon on a day in September this year. A brief sighting, and he or she was something like 200 yards away, heading into brush by the side of a dirt road and then into a patch of woods.  You can hear coyotes yelping back and forth or all at once as a group every night, but seeing one is unusual. They have to be stealthy in order to stay alive, but they also have to eat. When humans have domestic animals in the area, these animals may become part of the coyote diet, resulting in the human-versus-coyote population dynamic. There's also the human-coyote-rabbit dynamic.  No joking there, just multiplication versus subtraction to maintain a sort of equilibrium.

16 October 2017

Actual appointments in '67 desk calendar

I moved these entries involving the 1967 IP Executive Calendar from their original posting dates in the fall of 2010 so they would correspond to some of the months and days shown on the calendar, only 50 years later.  Yes, the numbering of days of the month is the same this year as it was in '67, the year in which A Serious Man takes place.

My mother actually used these two calendar pages for writing down some appointments, upcoming visits from friends (the Murphree family from Ohio), and events. The red squirrel seems to be not so much caught in the act as caught unawares after the act was done.  The elk speaks for himself. The last word looks like "Dumb" but is actually (misspelled) "Bumb."





31 August 2017

22 August 2017

Art Hobson offers new insights on Schrödinger’s cat

Before returning to my discussion of Planck's discovery of the quantum of action via his analysis of black-body radiation, I would like to provide a couple of links to Art Hobson's recent writings about the quantum superposition problem. Hobson is an emeritus physics professor, or I should say a retired physics professor, at the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville.

Schrödinger’s cat is supposed to be one of the main themes of this blog, so, yeh, it's about time I got around to writing something about it again.  Hobson discusses and claims to resolve the paradox of the quantum superposition of the live and dead cat by using the concepts of entanglement and correlation.  Here is the abstract of his arXiv.org article titled Resolving Schrödinger’s Cat:


Schrodinger's famous cat has long been misunderstood. According to quantum theory and experiments with entangled systems, an entangled state such as the Schrodinger's cat state is neither a superposition of states of either subsystem nor a superposition of compound states of the composite system, but rather a nonlocal superposition of correlations between pairs of states of the two subsystems. The entangled post-measurement state that results from an ideal measurement is not paradoxical, but is merely a coherent superposition of two statistical correlations at "zero phase angle," i.e. at 100% positive correlation. Thus the state of the radioactive nucleus and Schrodinger's cat is as follows: an undecayed nucleus is 100% positively correlated with an alive cat, and (i.e. superposed with) a decayed nucleus is 100% positively correlated with a dead cat. The superposition consists merely in the fact that both correlations are simultaneously true. Despite many published statements to the contrary, this superposition is not paradoxical. It is in fact what one expects intuitively.

Actually, the concept of simultaneity is in there too!

Hobson also discusses The Cat Problem on the Oxford University Press website advertising his new book, Tales of the Quantum: Understanding Physics' Most Fundamental Theory.

Another new book with a different take on The Cat Problem and on quantum physics in general is Qbism: The Future of Quantum Physics, by Hans Christian von Baeyer.  He's one of my favorite physics book writers but I don't have a copy of this new book yet, so I'm reserving comment.  One fellow who has commented on the book already is Kelvin J. McQueen, who doesn't think Quantum Bayesianism (Qbism) as described by von Baeyer is on the right track to resolve the "notorious paradoxes of quantum theory."

Then there's the new book by Gerard 't Hooft, the main man in the renormalization business (Physics Nobel Prize shared with former adviser and buddy M. J. G. Veltman in 1999), called The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics.

Yow!  So many new interpretations lately of quantum theory.  I'm still working on mine!

For a relevant discussion of the hardest thing to understand about quantum mechanics--which is also its most characteristic feature--see the History and the Concept sections of the Wikipedia article on entanglement.

22 July 2017

Rising mist(s)

Another of my comments written on the '67 calendar:


Okay, only one or two more, plus some actual appointments written on the calendar, later.

18 June 2017

Leave it to beaver

On second thought, anybody who's needed to get a cat into a pet carrier knows the unlikelihood of a cat going to sleep inside a darkened box.  Not to mention the unlikelihood of even getting the cat in the box.  The cat would more probably knock over the intended experimental equipment and yowl until you let him or her out.  And who could blame 'em?  Was old uncle Erwin--old (40s) compared to Heisenberg and Dirac (20s)--making a subtle joke by suggesting doing the experiment with a cat?  Was he thinking that since the mouse is usually the poor creature who gets inhumanely put in a humanly concocted experiment that he'd use it's opposite, a cat?  Or was there a cat asleep on his desk when he thought up the experiment?

Whatever the case may be, the next 1967 calendar animal I put words in the mouth of was a beaver:



No, I wasn't very good at spelling as a 12 and 13 year old kid.   I got better.

17 June 2017

Sleeping cat?

In 1998, when I was taking an undergraduate quantum physics class taught by Steven Weinberg at UT-Austin (a rare thing for him to teach an undergrad course--he gave us only homework sets and no exams, which I very much liked), the book for the course was Intro to Quantum Mechanics, by David J. Griffiths.  Yep, the one I mentioned earlier, with a drawing of a live cat on the front and a dead cat on the back.  When the 10-year-old daughter of my girlfriend at the time saw the book she called the cat on the back a "sleeping cat."  I told her that it was actually supposed to be a dead cat, according to the Schrodinger thought experiment that was represented by the two drawings.

Now I'm thinking why not let the cat have a 50% chance of being awake or asleep? Have the experiment use a sleeping potion released in the sealed box with the cat instead of cyanide gas.

Well, the problem with that is the cat could enter this state, the state of being asleep, independently of what the experimental apparatus does.  Who could blame the cat in a dark closed box for going to sleep?  But this possibility would mess up the 2-state probability transferance from atomic system (metastable quantum state) to the cat.

But, on the other hand, the cat could also enter the state of being dead independently!  If you put it in a sealed box, it's not gonna live too long without air being pumped in! Or it could have a heart attack or whatever, and this possibility is ignored by usual discussions of the "cat paradox."

So when I get around to actually discussing the significance of Schrodinger's cat, I'll use a sleeping cat versus an awake cat and see how that works out...

Three semesters after I took the Weinberg quantum course, I took yet another undergraduate quantum mechanics class, this time at the University of South Carolina, and it even used the same book.  However, it was a traditional class. Exams, including a final exam, were given.  I'd made an "A" in Weinberg's difficult-homework-based class.  Using the same book in a standard homework-and-exam-based class a year and a half later--with actually a very good teacher (Weinberg was okay, but taught like he was giving one of his research seminars--lecturing, with little if any class participation encouraged)--I made a "B".